The Australian Labor Party is facing intensifying internal pressure over its Middle East policy, with senior figures questioning the strategic coherence of the government's approach to Hamas and the Palestinian Authority.

The controversy has been amplified by comments from Pat Conroy, who has defended the party's position as a "balanced compromise" despite mounting criticism that it lacks strategic credibility.

Critics argue that the current policy framework makes a mockery of Conroy's previous characterization of former Prime Minister Robert Menzies as an appeaser.

The debate centers on whether the Labor government is demanding sufficient disarmament from Hamas, particularly in light of the uncertainty surrounding the implementation of the roadmap announced by Donald Trump.

Skepticism remains high regarding whether Hamas will honor any disarmament agreements, given the group's history and ideological stance.

This policy dispute comes amid broader tensions within the Labor Party following its recent national conference.